Content Options

Content Options

COBS 2.3 Inducements relating to business other than MiFID, equivalent third country or optional exemption business and insurance-based investment products

Interpretation

COBS 2.3.-1 R RP

6In this section ‘giving advice, or providing services, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme’ includes:

  1. (1)

    giving advice or assistance to an employer on the operation of such a scheme;

  2. (2)

    taking, or helping the employer to take, the steps that must be taken to enable an employee to become a member of such a scheme; and

  3. (3)

    giving advice to an employee, pursuant to an agreement between the employer and the adviser, about the benefits that are, or might be, available to the employee as an actual or potential member of such a scheme.

Application

COBS 2.3.-1A R RP

12This section does not apply to:

  1. (1)

    12giving advice, or providing services, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme where that scheme is a qualifying scheme; 13

  2. (2)

    12a firm in relation to MiFID, equivalent third country or optional exemption business (but see COBS 2.3A (Inducements relating to MiFID, equivalent third country or optional exemption business and insurance-based investment products)); or13

  3. (3)

    a firm carrying on an insurance distribution activity in relation to an insurance-based investment product.13

COBS 2.3.-1B G RP

The rules governing fees, commissions and non-monetary benefits which may be paid or provided in respect of qualifying schemes are found in COBS 19.6.

COBS 2.3.-1C G

12This section does not apply to the provision of independent advice or restricted advice on a retail investment product in the course of MiFID, equivalent third country or optional exemption business. A firm providing such a service should refer instead to COBS 2.3A (Inducements relating to MiFID, equivalent third country or optional exemption business) and COBS 6.1A (Adviser charging and remuneration).

Rule on inducements

COBS 2.3.1 R RP

A firm must not pay or accept any fee or commission, or provide or receive any non-monetary benefit, in relation to designated investment business12 carried on for a client other than:

  1. (1)

    a fee, commission or non-monetary benefit paid or provided to or by the client or a person on behalf of the client; or

  2. (2)

    a fee, commission or non-monetary benefit paid or provided to or by a third party or a person acting on behalf of a third party, if:

    1. (a)

      the payment of the fee or commission, or the provision of the non-monetary benefit does not impair compliance with the firm's duty to act in the best interests of the client; and

    2. (b)

      the existence, nature and amount of the fee, commission or benefit, or, where the amount cannot be ascertained, the method of calculating that amount, is clearly disclosed to the client, in a manner that is comprehensive, accurate and understandable, before the provision of the service;1

      1. (i)

        this requirement only applies to business other than the carrying on by a UKUCITS management company14of the collective portfolio management activities of investment management and administration for the relevant scheme12 if it includes10:

        1. (A)

          10giving a personal recommendation in relation to a retail investment product, pension transfer, pension conversion, pension opt-out15 or P2P agreement;10 or

        2. (B)

          10giving advice, or providing services, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme;

        556
      2. (ii)

        where this requirement applies to business other than the carrying on by a UKUCITSmanagement company14of the collective portfolio management activities of investment management and administration for the relevant scheme12, a firm is not required to make a disclosure to the client in relation to a non-monetary benefit permitted under (a) and which falls within the table of reasonable non-monetary benefits in COBS 2.3.15 G as though that table were part of this rule for this purpose only;1

      3. (iii)

        this requirement does not apply to a firm giving basic advice; and31

        3
    3. (c)

      in relation to the carrying on by a UK UCITS management company or EEA UCITS management company14 of the collective portfolio management activities of investment management and administration for the relevant scheme12 or when carrying on a regulated activity in relation to a retail investment product or a pension transfer, pension conversion or pension opt-out15 or when advising on P2P agreements, 10the payment of the fee or commission, or the provision of the non-monetary benefit is designed to enhance the quality of the service to the client; or31

      83
  3. (3)

    proper fees which enable or are necessary for the provision of designated investment business12, such as custody costs, settlement and exchange fees, regulatory levies or legal fees, and which, by their nature, cannot give rise to conflicts with the firm's duties to act honestly, fairly and professionally in accordance with the best interests of its clients; or15

  4. (4)

    an employer or trustee funded pension advice charge.15

[Note:12 articles 29(1) and 29(2) of the UCITS implementing Directive]7

12

1
COBS 2.3.1A R RP

7 COBS 2.3.1 R applies to a UK UCITS management company14when providing collective portfolio management services, as if references to a client, were references to any UCITS it manages

[Note: article 29(1) of the UCITS implementing Directive]

COBS 2.3.2 R RP

A firm will satisfy the disclosure obligation under this section if it:

  1. (1)

    discloses the essential arrangements relating to the fee, commission or non-monetary benefit in summary form;

  2. (2)

    undertakes to the client that further details will be disclosed on request; and

  3. (3)

    honours the undertaking in (2).

[Note:12article 29(2) of the UCITS implementing Directive]7

COBS 2.3.2A R RP

7 COBS 2.3.2 R applies to a UK UCITS management company14when providing collective portfolio management services, as if references to a client were references to a Unitholder of the scheme.

[Note: article 29(2) of the UCITS implementing Directive]

Guidance on inducements

COBS 2.3.3 G RP

The obligation of a firm to act honestly, fairly and professionally in accordance with the best interests of its clients includes both the client's best interests rule and the duties under Principles 1 (integrity), 2 (skill, care and diligence) and 6 (customers' interests).

COBS 2.3.4 G RP

[deleted]12

1
COBS 2.3.4A G

12A UCITS management company is subject to specific rules on inducements and research in COBS 18.5B when executing orders for financial instruments for, or on behalf of, the UCITS it manages (see COBS 18.5B.6R and COBS 18 Annex 1).

COBS 2.3.5 G RP

For the purposes of this section, a non-monetary benefit would include the direction or referral by a firm of an actual or potential item of designated investment business to another person, whether on its own initiative or on the instructions of an associate.

COBS 2.3.6 G RP

[deleted]12

12

COBS 2.3.6A G RP

5 COBS 6.1A (Adviser charging and remuneration), COBS 6.1B (Retail investment product provider and operator of an electronic system in relation to lending and platform service provider 10requirements relating to adviser charging and remuneration), COBS 6.1C (Consultancy charging and remuneration) and COBS 6.1D (Product provider requirements relating to consultancy charging and remuneration) set out specific requirements as to when it is acceptable for a firm to pay or receive commissions, fees or other benefits:6

  1. (1)

    relating to the provision of a personal recommendation on retail investment products, pension transfers, pension conversions, pension opt-outs15 or P2P agreements10; or

    6
  2. (2)

    for giving advice, or providing services, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme.6

COBS 2.3.7 G RP

The fact that a fee, commission or non-monetary benefit is paid or provided to or by an appointed representative12 does not prevent the application of the rule on inducements.

2
COBS 2.3.8 G RP

[deleted]12

Paying commission on non-advised sales of packaged products51

COBS 2.3.9 G RP

1The following guidance and evidential provisions provide examples of arrangements the FCA believes will breach the client's best interests rule if a firm sells or arranges5 the sale of a packaged product for a retail client.

5
COBS 2.3.10 E RP
  1. (1)

    1If a firm is required to disclose commission (see COBS 6.4) to a client in relation to the sale of a packaged product (other than in relation to arrangements between firms that are in the same immediate group) the firm should not enter into any of the following:

    1. (a)

      volume overrides, if commission paid in respect of several transactions is more than a simple multiple of the commission payable in respect of one transaction of the same kind; and

    2. (b)

      an agreement to indemnify the payment of commission on terms that would or might confer an additional financial benefit on the recipient in the event of the commission becoming repayable.

  2. (2)

    Contravention of (1) may be relied upon as tending to establish contravention of the rule on inducements (COBS 2.3.1 R).

COBS 2.3.11 G RP
  1. (1)

    1If a firm enters into an arrangement with another firm under which it makes or receives a payment of commission in relation to the sale of a packaged product that is increased in excess of the amount disclosed to the client, the firm is likely to have breached the rules on disclosure of charges, remuneration and commission (see COBS 6.4) and, where applicable, the rule on inducements in COBS 2.3.1R (2)(b), unless the increase is attributable to an increase in the premiums or contributions payable by that client.

Providing credit and other benefits to firms that give personal recommendations on retail investment products or P2P agreements

COBS 2.3.11A G RP

5The following guidance and evidential provisions provide examples of arrangements the FCA believes will breach the client's best interests rule in relation to a personal recommendation of a retail investment product or P2P agreement10to a retail client.

COBS 2.3.12 E RP
  1. (1)

    1This evidential provision applies in relation to a holding in, or the provision of credit to, a firm which holds itself out as making personal recommendations to retail clients on retail investment products or P2P agreements10, except where the relevant transaction is between persons who are in the same immediate group.

    55
  2. (2)

    A retail investment product provider5 or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10 should not take any step which would result in it:

    5
    1. (a)

      having a direct or indirect holding of the capital or voting power of a firm in (1); or

    2. (b)

      providing credit to a firm in (1) (other than continuing to facilitate the payment of an adviser charge or consultancy charge6 where it is no longer payable by the retail client, as described in COBS 6.1A.5 G or COBS 6.1C.6 G);56

      5

    unless all the conditions in (4) are satisfied. A retail investment product provider5 or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10 should also take reasonable steps to ensure that its associates do not take any step which would result in it having a holding as in (a) or providing credit as in (b).

    5
  3. (3)

    A firm in (1) should not take any step which would result in a retail investment product provider5 or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10 having a holding as in (2)(a) or providing credit as in (2)(b), unless all the conditions in (4) are satisfied.

    55
  4. (4)

    The conditions referred to in (2) and (3) are that:

    1. (a)

      the holding is acquired, or credit is provided, on commercial terms, that is terms objectively comparable to those on which an independent person unconnected to a retail investment product provider5 or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10 would, taking into account all relevant circumstances, be willing to acquire the holding or provide credit;

      5
    2. (b)

      the firm (or, if applicable, each of the firms) taking the step has reliable written evidence that (a) is satisfied;

    3. (c)

      there are no arrangements, in connection with the holding or credit, relating to the channelling of business from the firm in (1) to the retail investment product provider or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10;5 and

    4. (d)

      the retail investment product provider5 or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10 is not able, and none of its associates is able, because of the holding or credit, to exercise any influence over the personal recommendations made in relation to retail investment products5 or P2P agreements10 given by the firm or the advice given, or services provided to, an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme.6

      55
  5. (5)

    In this evidential provision, in applying (2) and (3) any holding of, or credit provided by, a retail investment product provider’s5 or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending’s10associate is to be regarded as held by, or provided by, that retail investment product provider or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending. 10.5

    55
  6. (6)

    [deleted]5

    5
  7. (7)

    Contravention of (2) or (3) may be relied upon as tending to establish contravention of the rule on inducements (COBS 2.3.1 R).

COBS 2.3.12A G RP

5Where a retail investment product provider or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending, 10or its associate, provides credit to a retail client of a firm making personal recommendations in relation to retail investment products or P2P agreements10 or giving advice, or providing services, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme6, this may create an indirect benefit for the firm and, to the extent that this is relevant, the provider of retail investment products or operator of an electronic system in relation to lending10may need to consider the examples in COBS 2.3.12E as if it had provided the credit to the firm.

COBS 2.3.13 G RP

1In considering the compliance of arrangements between members of the same immediate group with the rule on inducements (COBS 2.3.1 R), firms may wish to consider the evidential provisions in COBS 2.3.10 E and COBS 2.3.12 E, to the extent that these are relevant.

Reasonable non-monetary benefits1

COBS 2.3.14 G RP
  1. (1)

    1In relation to the sale of retail investment products,5 the table on reasonable non-monetary benefits (COBS 2.3.15 G) indicates the kind of benefits which are capable of enhancing the quality of the service provided to a client and, depending on the circumstances, are capable of being paid or received without breaching the client's best interests rule. However, in each case, it will be a question of fact whether these conditions are satisfied.

    5
  2. (2)

    The guidance in the table on reasonable non-monetary benefits is not relevant to non-monetary benefits which may be given by a retail investment product provider5 or its associate to its own representatives. The guidance in this provision does not apply directly to non-monetary benefits provided by a firm to another firm that is in the same immediate group. In this situation, the rules on commission equivalent (COBS 6.4.3 R), the requirements on a retail investment product provider making a personal recommendation in respect of its own retail investment products (COBS 6.1A.9 R)5 or the requirements on a firm giving advice, or providing services, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or group stakeholder pension scheme produced by the firm (COBS 6.1C.8 R) 6 will apply.

11
COBS 2.3.15 G RP

1This table belongs to COBS 2.3.14 G.

11

Gifts, Hospitality and Promotional Competition Prizes

1

A retail investment product provider5 giving and a firm receiving gifts, hospitality and promotional competition prizes of a reasonable value.

5

Promotion

2

A retail investment product provider5 assisting another firm to promote its retail investment products5 so that the quality of its service to clients is enhanced. Such assistance should not be of a kind or value that is likely to impair the recipient firm's ability to pay due regard to the interests of its clients, and to give advice on, and recommend, retail investment products5 available from the recipient firm's whole range or ranges.

5 5 5

Joint marketing exercises

3

A retail investment product provider5 providing generic product literature (that is, letter heading, leaflets, forms and envelopes) that is suitable for use and distribution by or on behalf of another firm if:

5

(a)

the literature enhances the quality of the service to the client and is not primarily of promotional benefit to the retail investment product provider;5 and

5

(b)

the total costs (for example, packaging, posting, mailing lists) of distributing such literature to its client are borne by the recipient firm.

4

A retail investment product provider5 supplying another firm with 'freepost' envelopes, for forwarding such items as completed applications, medical reports or copy client agreements.

5

5

A retail investment product provider5 supplying product specific literature (for example, key features documents, minimum information) to another firm if:

5

(a)

the literature does not contain the name of any other firm; or

(b)

if the name of the recipient firm is included, the literature enhances the quality of the service to the client and is not primarily of promotional benefit to the recipient firm.

6

A retail investment product provider5 supplying draft articles, news items and financial promotions for publication in another firm's magazine, only if in each case any costs paid by the product provider for placing the articles and financial promotions are not more than market rate, and exclude distribution costs.

5

Seminars and conferences

7

A retail investment product provider5 taking part in a seminar organised by another firm or a third party and paying toward the cost of the seminar, if:

5

(a)

its participation is for a genuine business purpose; and

(b)

the contribution is reasonable and proportionate to its participation and by reference to the time and sessions at the seminar when its staff play an active role.

Technical services and information technology

8

A retail investment product provider5 supplying a 'freephone' link to which it is connected.

5

9

A retail investment product provider5 supplying another firm with any of the following:

5

(a)

quotations and projections relating to its retail investment products5 and, in relation to specific investment transactions (or for the purpose of any scheme for review of past business), advice on the completion of forms or other documents;

5

(b)

access to data processing facilities, or access to data, that is related to the retail investment product provider’s5 business;

5

(c)

access to third party electronic dealing or quotation systems that are related to the retail investment product provider's5 business; and

5

(d)

software that gives information about the retail investment product provider's retail investment products5 or which is appropriate to its business (for example, for use in a scheme for review of past business or for producing projections or technical product information).

5

10

A retail investment product provider5 paying cash amounts or giving other assistance to a firm not in the same immediate group for the development of software or other computer facilities necessary to operate software supplied by the retail investment product provider,5 but only to the extent that by doing so it will generate equivalent cost savings to itself or clients.

5 5

11

A retail investment product provider5 supplying another firm with information about sources of mortgage finance.

5

12

A retail investment product provider5 supplying another firm with generic technical information in writing, not necessarily related to the product provider's business, when this information states clearly and prominently that it is produced by the product provider or (if different) supplying firm.

5

Training

13

A retail investment product provider5 providing another firm with training facilities of any kind (for example, lectures, venue, written material and software).

5

Travel and accommodation expenses

14

A retail investment product provider5 reimbursing another firm's reasonable travel and accommodation expenses when the other firm:

5

(a)

participates in market research conducted by or for the retail investment product provider;5

5

(b)

attends an annual national event of a United Kingdom trade association, hosted or co-hosted by the retail investment product provider;5

5

(c)

participates in the retail investment product provider’s5 training facilities (see 13);

5

(d)

visits the retail investment product provider’s5United Kingdom office in order to:

5

(i)

receive information about the retail investment product provider's5 administrative systems; or

5

(ii)

attend a meeting with the retail investment product provider5 and an existing or prospective client of the receiving firm.

5
COBS 2.3.16 G RP

1In interpreting the table of reasonable non-monetary benefits, retail investment product providers5 should be aware that where a benefit is made available to one firm and not another, this is more likely to impair compliance with the client's best interests rule and that, where any benefits of substantial size or value (such as adviser training programmes or significant software) are made available to firms that are subject to the rules on adviser charging and remuneration (COBS 6.1A) or consultancy charging and remuneration (COBS 6.1C),9 these benefits should be made available equally across those firms if they are provided at all.5

5
COBS 2.3.16A G RP

5In interpreting the table of reasonable non-monetary benefits, a firm that provides a personal recommendation in relation to a retail investment product to a retail client or gives advice, or provides a service, to an employer in connection with a group personal pension scheme or a group stakeholder pension scheme6 should be aware that acceptance of benefits on which the firm will have to rely for a period of time is more likely to impair compliance with the client's best interests rule. For example, accepting services which provide access to another firm's systems or software on which the firm will need to rely to gain access to the firm'sclient data in the future, would be likely to conflict with the rule on inducements (COBS 2.3.1R).

Application of guidance on reasonable non-monetary benefits

COBS 2.3.16B R

12The guidance on reasonable non-monetary benefits in COBS 2.3.14G to COBS 2.3.16AG does not apply to a firm which:

  1. (1)

    makes personal recommendations to retail clients in relation to retail investment products, pension transfers, pension conversions, pension opt-outs15 or P2P agreements, and to which COBS 6.1A (Adviser charging and remuneration) applies; or

  2. (2)

    is a retail investment product provider, a platform service provider or a firm which is an operator of an electronic system in relation to lending to which COBS 6.1B (Retail investment product provider, operator of an electronic system relating to lending, and platform service provider requirements relating to adviser charging and remuneration) applies.

COBS 2.3.16C G

12However, COBS 6.1A and COBS 6.1B do permit minor non-monetary benefits which meet the relevant requirements set out in COBS 6.1A.5AR(2).

Record keeping: inducements

COBS 2.3.17 R RP
  1. (1)

    A firm must make a record of the information disclosed to the client in accordance with COBS 2.3.1R (2)(b)4 and must keep that record for at least five years from the date on which it was given.

    4
  2. (2)

    A firm must also 4make a record of each benefit given to another firm which does not have to be disclosed to the client4in accordance with COBS 2.3.1R (2)(b)(ii),4 and must keep that record for at least five years from the date on which it was given.1

    4

12